Eviction, desperation artfully driven home
This is a tbo.com article.
Set in Orlando suburbs, the movie plunges into the ugly, contentious dramas of foreclosure. It’s a war movie where thresholds are the battle lines.
“This is our home!” cries Andrew Garfield’s Dennis Nash from his doorway when police and a real estate broker for the bank, Rick Carver (Michael Shannon), gather on his lawn to evict him, his young son (Noah Lomax) and his mother (Laura Dern).
It’s a scene that “99 Homes,” opening today in theaters, plays out repeatedly, sometimes with tears, sometimes with blood and always with a tragic sense of invasion for the turned-out families spilled onto sidewalks.
The central twist of the film is that once Nash, a jack-of-all-trades carpenter whose work has dried up along with new home construction, finds himself out of options, he is lured into working for Carver. He’s a Faustian figure: a white-suited devil on a cellphone making a fortune profiting on the misfortunes of others.
Shacked up in a low-rent motel and with his family’s survival very much in question, Nash takes the job. He soon finds himself on the other side of foreclosures, explaining to others that they are now trespassing on the bank’s property. Gobs of money, some of it underhandedly made, ease his guilt.
Garfield, in his first post-”Spiderman” movie and most adult role to date, excels in capturing Nash’s desperate transition from the breathless panic of losing his home to his reluctant and dubious rebirth.
As he so often is, Shannon is a towering force. His Carver is ruthlessly emotionless, rationalizing his role as merely a cog in a system controlled by larger entities: banks, the government.
He drives down the block, eyeing each house for repossession. His own mansion, he says, he’s had for 18 months but will flip by New Year’s. He’s a ruthless realist operating in a corrupt system: “Don’t get emotional about real estate,” he repeats.
The real villain of “99 Homes” lies somewhere off-screen. It’s the rigged apparatus — predatory lending, unfair mortgage rates, bailed-out banks — that has produced both the unfairly evicted and the likes of Carver. “America doesn’t bail out the losers,” Carver says in his big speech. But his hint of relief in the film’s climactic moment suggests he, too, feels trapped by the dehumanizing system.
Bahrani, who wrote the script with Ami Naderi, has specialized in socially conscious tales. His first film, “Man Push Cart,” tenderly profiles the life of a Pakistani pushcart vendor in New York. His last, “At Any Price,” with Zac Efron and Dennis Quaid, is a melodrama of a Midwestern farming family.
His touch isn’t always light. It’s not every director who will, after stretching out every harrowing moment of Nash’s eviction, then cue the arrival of the son’s school bus just when men are emerging with armfuls of their things.
But where many well-meaning social dramas inevitably turn soggy with moralizing, the visceral “99 Homes” keeps its fire.